Pile and Soil Stiffness in Solar Plant Foundations: Why Load Tests Matter

 

engWhen designing foundations for solar farms, it is vital to consider both pile stiffness and soil stiffness; neither should be ignored. While pile stiffness is usually estimable with reasonable accuracy, soil stiffness is far more challenging to measure precisely. These uncertainties can impact both safety and reliability. That is why pile load tests (POT) are essential: they verify design assumptions, enhance safety,                                          and help keep project costs in check.

Why Pile and Soil Stiffness Are Critical in Solar Plant Foundation Design

Insufficiently embedded piles (too short piles) may fail to withstand lateral loads, such as those generated by wind, leading to structural failure and increased project costs. Simply increasing pile length is not always effective. If the pile lacks stiffness, loads won’t be appropriately transferred to the deeper, more stable soil layers.

In many cases, selecting a stiffer pile cross-section is a more efficient strategy. Greater stiffness allows for reduced embedment depth while still providing the required load-bearing capacity.

Three different pile cross sections (example)

   Three Example Pile Cross-Sections

 

Stiff vs. Flexible Piles

Consider two rods representing piles of different stiffness levels. These could be either driven or screw pile foundations:

Pfahlsteifigkeit, Länge und Steifigkeit des Untergrundes: Anschauliches Modell zur Erklärung der Wechselwirkung zwischen diesen drei Parametern

Pile Stiffness, Length, and Subgrade Modulus: Illustrating the Interaction Between Key Design Parameters

  • Left rod: This represents a new foundation with enough stiffness. It handles horizontal loads well.
  • Right rod: This one is thinner or maybe corroded, so it’s less rigid. It bends a lot more under the same load.

This variation becomes especially problematic in solar table foundations when piles with unequal stiffness are installed in sequence. The result is a “zipper effect,” where stiffer piles are overloaded due to uneven load transfer.

Risks of Incorrect Pile Foundation Design
  • Structural failure due to inadequate lateral resistance.
  • Material wastage when pile tips extend into soil layers that do not contribute to load capacity.
  • Increased costs from over-dimensioning without addressing stiffness.
  • Dynamic effects during load reversal scenarios, particularly for screw foundations, where corrosion at joints increases slack and decreases stiffness.

These issues highlight the importance of precise pile-soil interaction analysis for reliable solar plant foundations.

AquaSoli’s Approach: Reliable Data for Safer Designs

At AquaSoli, we carry out pile load tests to accurately assess the bending stiffness of the pile-soil system. To ensure long-term durability, we also perform:

  • On-site soil sampling
  • Laboratory analyses of soil corrosiveness
  • Risk assessments for pile corrosion

This comprehensive approach provides reliable data that results in safer designs, optimised material use, and long-term performance.

Building Stronger Solar Plant Foundations

By optimising pile selection based on pile stiffness and pile-soil interaction, engineers can balance safety, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness. This ensures reliable performance while minimising material use; meeting the needs of engineers, project managers, and stakeholders alike.

Contact AquaSoli today to learn how we can optimise your foundation design and ensure the long-term reliability of your solar project.AquaSoli

 

You are cordially invited to Vispiron Evening Dialogue!

AquaSoli Team is eager to meet you …

at  Vispirons excellent evening dialogue “Sustainable Energy to Flowing Water”, 20th of June, 6pm; => Register here

AquaSoli attends with its booth team including CEO Juergen Schmid.

Invitation to Vispiron Evening Dialogue, Wednesday, 20th of June 2018 (English):

(The term of application has been elongated… 😉

Invitation_eng_logo

 

 

 

 

 

 

Einladung zu Vispiron Abend Dialog (Deutsch):

Anmeldefrist wurde verlängert!180608 TLE page1

 

 

 

180608 TLE page2

Professional AquaSoli Geotech Analysis helps to cut down Project Cost

The Clients experience on project “AB” illustrates typical issues with selecting racking and doing facility design before characterizing the site and soils bearing capacity. It also demonstrates how AquaSoli leverages our experience and contacts to solve expensive design and deployment issues.

Pile driver machine

If the Posts Length exceeds the Pile Driver Machines Capability something has gone wrong in the planning process…

and might result in exploding Machinery Cost.

A Client came to us with a racking system and asked us to perform geotechnical site assessment, analytical load testing and foundation design for 3 projects.

On the largest site conventional foundation design specified a total pile length of 13.5 feet for the single center post racking system. Our experience indicated that a pile of this length requires special handling which increases installation costs as much as 30%.

Working with the rack manufacturer and re-analyzing the dense load test data we collected, AquaSoli identified two cost saving foundation alternatives.

1. Discussions with the manufacturer applications engineers determined that the specified foundation stickup included adjustability to accommodate site grade variation. Our site experience allowed the manufacturer to agree to reduce the specified stickup, thus shortening the required pile length.

2. Our analytical foundation load testing identified anomalous vertical bearing behaviour for the preferred foundation profile. By rigorously reanalyzing the soils data and foundation behaviour, we provided a suitable design based on an alternative foundation profile with a reduced embedment depth. The alternative profile design reduced pile length enough to allow the lowest cost installation technique.

The net result is that the client will save about 3 times the cost of our services in installation costs alone.

In addition we identified an opportunity to save as much as 10% on the materials costs by reducing the required foundation stickup.

On a second site we are working to solve a similar issue but resulting from weak horizontal bearing capacity. Site work determined that the soils were mechanically disturbed to a depth of 5 feet. The weak soils and single post rack design dictated a total pile length that required installation by a specialized pile driver. Use of the oversized pile driver increased projected installation costs as much as 300%.

We have identified several alternatives to solve the issue. However by selecting the racking before understanding soils conditions the Client adversely impacted both their schedule and project costs and risked a great deal more.

Lesson to learn: If solar specific site evaluation and load testing is completed first, AquaSoli can recommend standard design and racking alternatives that provide routine solutions for individual site issues. Routine solutions support low costs and schedule compliance. (Author of this text: US VP Bob Donaldson)

Please contact AquaSoli

in USA +1.508.982.4811

in Japan +81.8050309569

in MENA +962.7.9650.4325

in Europe +49.89.6223376815

 

AquaSoli now in Jordan, in UK and at InterSolar in Munich

f2c1855b-2521-4a4b-929c-e5e978e0b300

 

 

Intersolar 2014

From 4th to 6th June 2014 in Munich

Also this year, AquaSoli is back with a booth at the Intersolar in Munich. We hope to welcome you at our booth in Hall C4; booth 285.

Our team is happy to inform you in a personal consultation, how we can assist you with your projects in the future. Best arrange a date soon. Please send an email to info@aquasoli.de or click on the button below.

Click for appointment

8c7d803d-6824-4327-bbf8-afe2254419ac

 

 

Jordan

Local contact

In order to serve all projects in the Middle East even more reliable in in the future, now the Head of MENA is permanently baesed in the new office in Amman. Currently, it was again geotechnical analysis and pull-out tests for a configured PV project to perform.

Who said that it does not rain in the desert? Thanks to our expertise your projects are, resistant designed, even under extreme conditions at any time according to the state of the art.

7d50a406-4d81-4776-a9bd-0986969dd9a6

 

 

 

492e3bd5-4d3e-468e-8c25-3b7b8c14689d

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

United Kingdom

AquaSolis Gayk ramming machine back in the UK

Currently we can offer short-term soil investigations and pull-out tests for PV projects in the UK, since we have decided to ship the necessary machinery to the island. Thus you benefit from short-term availability and low travel costs.

eb9f7bb2-14f1-432d-b1c5-dc1971b6348e

Copyright © 2014 AquaSoli GmbH & Co. KG, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this because of direct contact with one of our company’s representatives.

Our mailing address is:
AquaSoli GmbH & Co. KG

Birkenleiten 41

Munich 81543

Germany

Add us to your address book

Solar Foundation Risk Assessment And Mitigation

Solar Foundation Risk Management And Mitigation

image002

 Recovering value and performance by addressing foundation failure vulnerability

 

For commercial and utility scale facilities, the comparative costs of various degrees of foundation risk abatement can be thought of in the following terms:

  • The incremental cost of experienced geotechnical site assessment, foundation design and early project involvement is thousands of dollars.
  • The cost of geotechnical risk assessment for suspect foundations is about the cost of a typical geotechnical site assessment.
  • The cost of foundation risk abatement is comparative to the materials and installation cost of the original foundations.
  • The cost of foundation failure remediation encompasses racking and modules and can approach the initial value of the installation.

 

image008AquaSoli’s perspective on foundation failure and ground component vulnerability stems from 10 years, 1000 projects and 10 gigawatts of experience.  Our work in this area grows with the in-service history of commissioned facilities.  Operational time increases likelihood that a latent foundation risk is actualized by the triggering atmospheric, climatic, and geotechnical conditions.

AquaSoli has a number of tools for addressing risk mitigation:

  • Our baseline understanding of foundation performance and vulnerability comes from designing with most major racks and foundation configurations in all terrains and environments.
  • Over the last 10 years, AquaSoli has compiled an extensive database of empirical design parameters from more than 1000 projects, including foundation remediation.
  • In-house laboratory facilities allow us to model soil profiles, site variables, and foundation reactions, to help replicate real world conditions for testing failure modes.
  • Typical foundation risk and failure mitigation projects add to our body of experience.

 image006

With experience in failure mode analysis and deploying mitigation strategies, AquaSoli offers cost effective alternatives for risk reduction.  Mitigation is usually a fraction of the cost of failure remediation.  Timely implementation can alleviate the performance and financial liability of unquantified risk.  AquaSoil provides risk valuation, mitigation design and deployment, remediation design and construction supervision.  In addition, we will certify the performance of our corrective action for existing facilities.

image004Want to learn more? – Contact us at info@aquasoli.com or call +1 415 230 2062